
Palworld Lawyers Claim Titanfall 2, Ark, and Zelda Crush Nintendo's Patents
Apr 20, 2025 4:58 PMPocketpair is currently in a legal battle with Nintendo regarding patent infringement claims against its game Palworld. The developer argues that the patents in question are invalid because similar concepts and mechanics were already present in several prior games, including Ark: Survival Evolved, Tomb Raider, and The Legend of Zelda. This challenge is based on the assertion that Nintendo's patents, filed after Palworld's release, cannot be upheld since multiple games already demonstrated the mechanics they cover. Pocketpair's defense hinges on a range of examples from popular titles that they believe diminish the validity of Nintendo's claims, positioning Palworld as unique amidst a landscape filled with established games.
What are the implications of Pocketpair's legal battle with Nintendo for future game development?The outcome of this lawsuit could set significant precedents for intellectual property rights in the gaming industry. If Pocketpair successfully proves that Nintendo's patents are invalid, it may encourage other developers to challenge similar claims, fostering a more open environment for innovation in game mechanics and design.
Palworld is an action-adventure game that has garnered attention for its unique blend of monster-catching gameplay, reminiscent of Pokémon, combined with shooting elements, earning it the nickname "Pokémon with guns." Released in early 2024, the game allows players to capture and train creatures while also engaging in combat, making it stand out in the indie game space. Despite its legal challenges, Palworld continues to evolve, with regular updates that enhance gameplay and expand its reach on platforms like Nintendo Switch.

Samira Khan
Samira Khan is a narrative enthusiast with a keen eye for storytelling in games. Her literary approach to game criticism examines themes, character development, and plot structure, earning her a following among gamers who appreciate the art of narrating.
Follow us
Fans
Fans
Fans

This case feels like a potential turning point for how much inspiration is allowed in game design before it crosses into legal gray areas. Either way, it’s wild to see an indie studio go toe-to-toe with Nintendo—talk about David vs. Goliath vibes.

Man, if Pocketpair wins this, it could open the floodgates for more devs to push back against overly broad patents—imagine the creativity boom if studios aren’t constantly looking over their shoulders. That said, Nintendo’s lawyers are no joke, so this’ll be one to watch for sure.