In the latest Marvel Cinematic Universe buzz, Pedro Pascal is rumored to be the frontrunner for the role of Mister Fantastic in the upcoming Fantastic Four reboot directed by Matt Shakman. This potential casting has sparked debates among fans who had envisioned John Krasinski, following his cameo in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, to reprise the character in a full-length feature. Despite some skepticism about Pascal stepping into Reed Richards' shoes, others are pointing to his previous roles in 'The Mandalorian' and 'Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent' as evidence of his capability to handle both comedic and dramatic elements essential for the role.

While Krasinski's performance was well-received in his brief appearance as Mister Fantastic, he hasn't been invited back to the role, leading fans to question Marvel's decision. Discussions on social media platforms like Reddit and Twitter reflect a divide in the fanbase, with some comparing the casting situation to James Gunn's choice for Superman, where a relatively unknown actor, David Corenswet, was selected.

An unofficial poll among IGN readers shows a near split, with 52 percent feeling Pascal isn't the right fit for the character, highlighting the contentious nature of the casting. Despite the ongoing debates, Pascal's casting as Mister Fantastic has not been officially confirmed, but talks are reportedly moving forward positively. The Fantastic Four film is set to begin production early next year, targeting a May 2, 2025, release date, and is part of the MCU's eagerly anticipated Phase 5 lineup.