The recent nomination of "Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree" for the Game Awards 2024 has ignited heated discussions among fans regarding its eligibility. While many praise its expansive content and depth, others argue that as an expansion pack linked to the main game, it shouldn't compete with standalone games for Game of the Year. The controversy has led to calls for a separate category for best expansions within the awards. Despite the debate, the Game Awards insists that the quality and creativity of the content are paramount, allowing significant expansions like Shadow of the Erdtree to compete with major titles. Fans have expressed varying opinions, some supporting the nomination for its impressive value and playtime, while others lament the potential exclusion of other deserving titles.
Should expansion packs be considered for Game of the Year awards?Opinions are split on this issue. While some believe expansions like "Shadow of the Erdtree" should be honored for their substantial content and creativity, others argue that its nature as DLC disqualifies it from competing on the same level as standalone games.
"Elden Ring" released in early 2022 has made waves in the gaming community for its open-world design and challenging gameplay. Developed by FromSoftware, the game combines elements of RPG and action, culminating in a rich narrative and immersive world. The game's DLC, "Shadow of the Erdtree," adds significant content that expands upon the lore and gameplay mechanics, creating a robust experience that players have found deeply rewarding.
Alex Riverton
Alex Riverton is a seasoned journalist with over a decade of experience in the gaming industry. Known for their in-depth analysis and hands-on previews, Alex has built a reputation for insightful commentary on gameplay mechanics and storytelling in videogames.
Read more articles from Alex Riverton
Comments
It’s always a hot topic whenever expansions like Shadow of the Erdtree step into the Game of the Year ring Honestly, if it adds enough depth and creativity to the gaming experience, I think it deserves a shot—after all, more content equals more fun, right
It's always fascinating when a major expansion like Shadow of the Erdtree stirs the pot in gaming discussions. While I get the debate on whether expansions deserve a shot at Game of the Year, it's hard to deny the depth and creativity they can bring, rivaling even standalone titles.
It's always fascinating to see how passionate the gaming community can get over awards Whether it’s an expansion or a standalone title, the creativity and effort that goes into these projects deserve recognition, but I get the struggle of balancing those categories to keep things fair.