Hulu has officially renewed its legal drama series, All’s Fair, for a second season, much to the surprise of many given its poor critical reception. The show, starring Kim Kardashian alongside a talented ensemble including Sarah Paulson and Glenn Close, received a dismal 3% rating on Rotten Tomatoes from critics. However, audience scores contrast sharply at 66%. The announcement was made on the series’ social media, revealing that production for Season 2 will begin in Spring 2026. Fans can catch the remaining episodes of the current season, with the season finale set for December 12.

Why was All’s Fair renewed despite its critical failure?

The series appears to have a stronger audience response, which likely influenced Hulu's decision. While critics were harsh, the audience score on Rotten Tomatoes showed significant approval, suggesting that fans may be engaging positively with the show's story and characters.

All’s Fair represents a blend of comedy and drama, focusing on the complexities of love and legal battles. The series was created by Ryan Murphy, known for producing popular shows that often push boundaries and elicit strong reactions, making this renewal emblematic of his bold storytelling approach. The show features a notable cast and sharp writing, indicating that despite its rough reception, it has managed to carve out a viewership that resonates with its unique premise.